Will taking trehalose kill you?

Trehalose is a sugar consisting of two molecules of glucose. However unlike the sugar on top of a jelly doughnut, it does not display the qualities of glucose when introduced into the body as it resists breakdown back into the simple sugars. Trehalose has high water retention capabilities, and is used in food, cosmetics, and as a drug. Because of its physical properties, trehalose possesses unique capabilities when it comes to maintaining the structure of proteins. It acts like a chaperone ‘splinting’ proteins in place when conditions become inhospitable (such as becoming dried out or frozen). Some bacteria, fungi, plants and invertebrate animals synthesize it as a source of energy, and to survive freezing and lack of water.

It is because of their high trehalose content that certain fish, frogs and invertebrates can survive freezing (which normally destroys proteins) and permit them to come back to life after thawing out.

Trehalose also possesses the ability to induce a chemical activity called autophagy.[1] Autophagy, from the Ancient Greek αὐτόφαγος autóphagos, meaning “I eat myself”, is the cellular equivalent of a town’s department of sanitation, garbagemen who day in and day out remove the debris of metabolism. Not surprisingly, because of these two special properties, trehalose has been looked at as a possible nutraceutical treatment for Alzheimers Disease.[2]

But all news is not good in trehalose land.

There has been a recent flurry of news reports regarding a study linking trehalose to an increased severity of Clostridium difficile (‘C-diff’) infections, a gastrointestinal infection seen in immune-compromised hospital patients.[3]

This was a small study that was done in-vitro (cell culture). It did not show that trehalose caused C-diff infections, but rather, culturing C-diff organisms with trehalose seemed to increase the pathological behavior of the organism by increasing the preponderance of two particular strains, known as RT027 and RT078.

However the evidence is far from conclusive. Trehalose has been added to food since 1995 in Japan, but neither of the pathogenic strains studied have been linked to outbreaks there. In the U.S., data suggests that these pathogenic variants had emerged well before 2000 and were already prevalent in hospitals. The data from Canada is even weaker. Outbreaks of RT027-associated C-diff predated the approval of trehalose as a food ingredient there in late 2005.

One university microbiologist reviewing the paper was quoted as saying: “It would be a shame if as a society we took this off the table before we’re really sure that it’s a problem. Let’s reevaluate the epidemiology and make sure that it makes sense, and then let’s do clinical research to make sure that this indeed is relevant to sick patients.” (JAMA. Published online March 21, 2018)

Finally, we should really keep things in perspective: C-diff infection is typically seen in immune-compromised patients who have been overprescribed antibiotics. Although the incidence is rising, this is a rather small percentage of the overall population, even in hospitals. It is far from conclusive that these results would duplicate in actual people, as the amount of trehalose that was used in the cell culture was far greater than what one would expect to be exposed to, even if taking it as a supplement.

3 comments on “Will taking trehalose kill you?”

  1. Blaine Reply

    So glad you weighed in on this. A lot of junk studies out there and hyperventilating reportage of them. So glad you returned to blogging. Would love to hear more about the Geezer app you are developing

  2. JAK Reply

    I was healthy and wasn’t over prescribed antibiotics when I was diagnosed with C Diff. I was given one round (10 days) of clindamycin for mastitis 11 days postpartum and a few weeks later I was unfortunate enough to acquire this awful bacteria. 5 months of treatment and finally a FMT was the only thing that cured me. Well 2 years and 2 months later without any antibiotics since before my FMT and it appears as though this nasty bug has made its way back into my life. I have not taken anything or been exposed to anyone with an active (known) c diff infection and just in the matter of a few hours I went from fine to not fine. I have a hard time believing that our concern over this food additive is far from being unwarranted or something to take so lightly.

Leave a Reply to Blaine Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *